Saturday, February 12, 2011

Functions of One Complex Variable (Graduate Texts in Mathematics - Vol 11) (v. 1)



Functions of One Complex Variable (Graduate Texts in Mathematics - Vol 11) (v. 1)
John B Conway | 1978-01-01 00:00:00 | Springer | 330 | Mathematics
"This book presents a basic introduction to complex analysis in both an interesting and a rigorous manner. It contains enough material for a full year's course, and the choice of material treated is reasonably standard and should be satisfactory for most first courses in complex analysis. The approach to each topic appears to be carefully thought out both as to mathematical treatment and pedagogical presentation, and the end result is a very satisfactory book for classroom use or self-study." --MathSciNet
Reviews
I have used this book back in my college days. I am amazed to see such a low rating on this book. This is one of the best books on complex analysis.

Mind you this is a Graduate Text in Mathematics. So it is intended to cover lot of ground using clear logical path. I agree to some extent that this book does not have lot of examples but a GTM is supposed to be like that. The way I used/read this book is to supplement it with other books on the topic. The proofs of theorems in this book are complete without any errors.



If you are a graduate student and want to learn complex analysis, this is the best book available out there.


Reviews
This book is a classic. Is good for an master degree course in mathematics.
Reviews
I concur with the reviewer Sidhant. I had tons of frustrations with this book this semester - it's so annoying. I just finished and reviewed Munkres' topology book, and Sterling Berberian's Fundamentals of Real Analysis, and the difference between these books and Conway's is (respectively) like the difference between say Bach and pure cacophony: cymbals, screeches, sirens, horns, etc.



Some of my complaints include, but are not limited to:



- No examples whatsoever; there may be one or two per chapter, jammed lamely into the body of the text

- The "expository prose" did nothing to elucidate the underlying mathematics; often Conway babbles for a while, then says something like "the proof is left to the reader". It came to a point last month where I simply just stopped reading the text and started to focus on just the theorems and proofs

- There were errors in some proofs, of omission and of commission. The two ugliest proofs I've ever seen in mathematics lie in this book: (1) a standard composition theorem for analytic functions done by cases (?) which ended with "the general case follows easily", and the argument was built upon sequences (?). In other books, the result is proved in three lines; (2) the Casorati-Weierstrass theorem: same sloppiness, but Wikipedia saved me with an elegant four-line proof. The open mapping theorem was almost incoherent; and a crucial part of it was left as an exercise. I managed to get this part from Adult Rudin with no problems, though.

- the exercises: some are actually fine, but many are obtuse, and obtusely stated. Ultimately - and this is a huge problem - one cannot trust whether or not exercises were written correctly, because of too much general and ubiquitous sloppiness.

- chapter 2 (mapping properties of analytic functions, mobius maps) is so poorly written i had to skip it entirely.



I have a whole list of complaints here on paper, that I collected while reading this book to expose when I reviewed it. It's simply not worth more time and effort to transcribe them.



Not the whole book is bad, the homotopy integral is treated fairly well (i guess), as are the earlier parts of complex integration, and isolated singularities. But all this stuff is elementary - the later chapters are what counts, and the two chapters following integration are a mess. I hate having to clean up SO MUCH of this book.



I recommend looking at Robert B. Ash's book, as it's only 15 dollars (and free online), compared to the 60 dollars which this book is, and more importantly he makes very wise comments regarding math pedagogy on his webpage. In contrast, Conway in his webpage is pictured drinking martinis; he was probably on his twelfth one when he began the writing of this book.



EDIT: i've been working through ash's online book from the start, and i notice the proofs are far more slick, yet far more intuitive. there are many more problems, and better, than in conway. plus there are hints and solutions - don't peek unless you really don't know where to start! ultimately i'm starting over somewhat. i can't pretend i know nothing after conway, but i've abandoned his book completely. i wasted a graduate semester on conway's garbage.
Reviews
This book was the recommended textbook for a course in Complex Analysis I took at college. I had already done a 1st course on analysis, but that didn't help me too much. This book, littered with loads of proofs and lemmas, is a little too terse, and the author expects students to understand a lot on their own. Concepts in Complex Analysis need to be demonstrated using examples, and diagrams, if possible. Like for eg. the concept of branches in complex functions. The book starts of defining the complex logrithmic function. The author never says what a branch exactly is. He writes down a hell lot of proofs and expects the student to figure out that the complex logarithm is infact a multi-valued function, and that a branch is essentially a "slice" of this multivalued function. Similiar problems crop up when the author discusses fractional linear transforms. Instead of showing whats happening with simple diagrams, the author makes things look extremely complicated with his equations and theorems. This book makes learning complex analysis a very mechanical exercise, devoid of all fun.




Reviews
We're using this book for my graduate level complex analysis course, and over all, I'm pleased with it. Aside from some goofy notation (i.e., an empty box to represent the empty set?), it's pretty well written. The pace of the text isn't too fast or too slow, and there are plenty of exercises of a varying degree of difficulty to help you learn the material. Another nice feature is the price; one can find it for less than $50, so it'll make a nice reference book even if it wasn't assigned for a class.

Download this book!

Free Ebooks Download